Over Voyager en DS9, het is interessant om het interview van Ronald D. Moore te lezen over zijn vertrekt bij Voyager als schrijver. Je zag toen al de contouren van het mismanagement bij Paramount/CBS en de toxische bedrijfscultuur die het bedrijf toen al had. Het is eigenlijk verwonderlijk dat in die omstandigheden Star Trek gemaakt kon worden, zoals Ronald D. Moore was dat succes voornamelijk te danken aan Michael Piller.
Zie ook:
defiant in "Star Trek - Nieuws, achtergronden & informatie"
Star Trek’s Civil War: Part 1
Star Trek’s Civil War: Part 2
Star Trek’s Civil War: Part 3
Star Trek’s Civil War: Part 4
Die zijn sowieso aanraders om te lezen hoe CBS/Paramount eigenlijk toxische organisaties waren vol mismanagement en wanbeleid.
Het interview:
Ronald D. Moore Q&A (reader mode gebruiken om dit leesbaar te maken)
I found on VOYAGER was suddenly it wasn’t about the work anymore. It wasn’t about making the best show that we possibly could; it was about all these other extraneous issues. It was about the politics of the show, and the strange sort of competition of egos within the writing staff and the producing staff and the management of the show. ‘Competition’ is probably a misleading term. The politics of the show were such that the egos of the people in charge of the series were threatened by the people who worked for them.
To be blunt, [writers] Bryan Fuller and Mike Taylor were treated very shabbily, and it pissed me off. They took a lot of crap, and the only reason it was done was to keep the guys on the top of the pyramid feeling good about themselves. It also had the effect of keeping the writing staff from working in concert as a group. The DS9 staff by contrast was very tight.
It’s about exploration, and it’s about the unknown, and all these cute catch phrases, but scratch the surface of that and there is really not much underneath it all. VOYAGER doesn’t really believe in anything. The show doesn’t have a point of view that I can discern. It doesn’t have anything really to say. I truly believe it simply is just wandering around the galaxy. It doesn’t even really believe in its own central premise, which is to me its greatest flaw."
[...] they were answering questions from the audience about the new ship. It was all very technical, and they were talking about the fact that in the premise this ship was going to have problems. It wasn’t going to have unlimited sources of energy. It wasn’t going to have all the doodads of the Enterprise. It was going to be rougher, fending for themselves more, having to trade to get supplies that they want. That didn’t happen
Moore continues. "It’s not truthful. On DEEP SPACE NINE, that was the watchword. We wanted it to be true. There was a lot of truth in DEEP SPACE NINE, a lot of difficult questions that we tried to answer, and some difficult questions that we couldn’t answer. DS9 was a real place, a truthful place; it was a place where we explored things on a real level. But VOYAGER doesn’t go there. It just will not go there. You are trying to tell the audience on the one hand, ‘We’re so far from home, and it’s going to take us so long, and we really wish we could get home. It’s rough out here.’ Janeway wrings her hands about all the things that she has sent the crew through. Then, it’s off to the holodeck. You can’t talk with any kind of a straight face about food rations and energy conservation, and having a real kitchen in the mess hall, when at the same time you’ve got the holodeck going. It’s such a facade, and no matter what kind of technobabble bullshit you come up with, the audience intuitively knows, again, that’s not truthful.
Hij is in dat interview behoorlijk kritisch, dat is ook wel te begrijpen aangezien hij op dat moment ook recentelijk het project had verlaten op slechte voet. Hoewel ik zelf niet zo scherp ben als hem, was het kernprobleem wel van Voyager dat het concept delta quadrant niet echt doordacht was. Uiteindelijk verviel Voyager in een serie die net zoals TNG vooral episodisch was, waarbij het delta quadrant overlevingsverhaal eigenlijk geen belangrijke rol speelde. Ze hadden Voyager achteraf net zo goed in de alpha quadrant kunnen laten.
"When I am weaker than you I ask you for freedom because that is according to your principles; when I am stronger than you I take away your freedom because that is according to my principles"- Frank Herbert